It's all about the love

A love story always has a beginning. As a child, I fell in love with grilled PB&J sandwiches, a rich buttery toasted crunchy bread-ful treat that resonated with my young soul. In October of 2016, following a spell as a cook in the northwoods, I was enjoying an almond-butter and blueberry jam sandwich. It was then I was met with idea that became PB&Jealous: what if we paired craft-grade nut butters with their perfect flavor matches and shared the results? Et voila, the journey had begun. 


Shortly thereafter, I recruited the help of dear friends and fellow PB&J-lovers Sam, Ashley and Taylor to help kick-start the sandwich story. 


- Keifer

Keifer, Chief of Flavor
Sam, Champion of Growth
Ashley, Master of Happiness
Taylor, Captain of Branding

We're proud to bring you flavors and varieties from all across the United States. We are passionate foodies, artists and truly care about the quality of product we source and ship.